I watched the newest edition to the franchise a couple of days ago, so it seems apt to pit films about people fighting to death…to the death. You know, like a Hunger Gamesception of sorts. May the odds be ever in their favour.
Sunrise on the Reaping
The most recent adaption of Suzanne Collins’ best sellers doesn’t disappoint. Focusing on Haymitch’s fight against the Capitol during the 50th anniversary of the Hunger Games, you get attached to characters quick and then become distraught as they’re quickly added to the slaughter. That’s thanks to the smart casting decision of mixing well-known actors with relative newcomers. Everyone brings talent to the games, and it’s an impressive feat for a lot of these individuals to make strong impressions with their understandably limited screen times. You know Haymitch has got all that plot armour with the prequel setup, but that doesn’t make Joseph Zada’s performance any less affecting.
There’s an argument to be made that the film could benefit from more brutality and hiking that age rating up a couple of levels, but the same case could be made for any of the Hunger Games films. Plus that would also knock out all of the YA audience that read the books, so that would be a dumb financial decision. Sunrise also displays some of the finest visual spectacle of the films to date, which makes sense considering how much technology has come on even since the OG film 14 years ago. Nonetheless, it’s brutal, beautiful and heartbreaking.
The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
The previous prequel to the original trilogy tracks the rise of archvillain President Snow and his tutelage of District 12 tribute Lucy Gray. This entry’s shining glory is the cast. It might make sense to zero in on the big players first, but I’ll start off by giving due praise to Peter Dinklage. This guy’s been on fire in just about every joint he’s starred in since I first witnessed his performance in Elf. He doesn’t need to be in the big roles to make a major impression, even if he is awesome in Game of Thrones. He’s awesome in X-Men: Days of Future Past, and he’s great in Wicked and Wicker (not to be confused despite the similar spellings and pronunciations). And Tom Blyth does great work here as the big bad. I saw this after watching the actor’s blistering performance in Wasteman, and I think he’ll be going places. He’s got that rizz, no doubt. Rachel Zegler’s also strong as our central protagonist, and Viola Davis is also great in her villainous role.
The problem comes with the rest of the film’s flabby narrative, particularly the ending, which is needly rushed despite the film’s chunky running time. The visuals are popping and the music’s decent too, but the screenplay needed a bit of dusting and cutting to fit everything together more succinctly.
Mockingjay Part 2
First point to address here. The filmmakers had no justification in splitting the final part of Collins’ OG trilogy into two separate films. They just saw the Harry Potter film starting a trend and then saw some bigass dollar signs. Nonetheless, the filmmakers do pretty well with what they’ve got in a bloated format, with some great action scenes, particularly when it swerves into more horrific gore (albeit within a 12A context) during the sewer scene. And there’s plenty of brutally effective traps, too (not of the Saw kind). The narrative bolts along at a decent pace as well. Performances are generally strong, although Josh Hutcherson’s a bit weaker here, partly because his character has nothing to do besides having meltdowns and getting crew members killed. A satisfying, if imperfect, end to the trilogy.
Mockingjay Part 1
I walked out on the field earlier for Peter Dinklage, and now I’m gonna bat for the MVP of both Mockingjay parts, the late great Philip Seymour Hoffman. He makes his first appearance in Catching Fire, but the guy’s got so much talent, even with Plutarch Heavensbee’s relatively short screentime. He can convey so much in a single facial expression, and even his vocal tones just project majesty. He’s been a major miss in the cinematic world, even if Jesse Plemons provides a strong interpretation of his character in Sunrise.
There’s much of a muchness here between part 2. There was just no reason to split the last book into two aside from financial greed. Performances are solid, but everything’s dragged out for the sake of making more dollar. Eh.
Catching Fire
One of those rare examples where the sequel eclipses the OG. Great story, great characters and plenty of compelling action. The stakes are high and the visuals are striking and memorable. The pacing’s also pitch perfect, propelled by a brilliant ending and set up for what could’ve been a great final entry in the OG trilogy if it hadn’t been split into two.
The Hunger Games
The one that started the epic franchise, and one of the strongest entries. A fairly simple dystopian concept was given gravitas and heart by the central players, and you felt real jeopardy watching these kids fight each other to the death. It’s an effect which maybe felt less shocking as you go on, just because you know the essential setup. A great beginning to a compelling YA franchise.
The final fighter in these games is ultimately going to be Catching Fire, just beating out the OG Hunger Games and Sunrise on the Reaping. Sure, I may have had less to say about my fave two, but I think they speak for themselves in terms of the insane popularity and praise they received at the time of release. It’s a big feat to better the original, but Catching Fire managed it with impressive acting and affecting performances across its stacked cast.
